whereis.gay
Pegasus On Church
Bars

Pegasus On Church

Gay bar in Toronto’s Church-Wellesley Village with games and pool tables

Toronto, Canada
4.4
865 reviews

Neighbourhood

Toronto

Category

Bars

Vibe

Board Games, Cocktails +2

Official website

About Pegasus On Church

Pegasus on Church is a long-running gay bar on Church Street in Toronto’s Church-Wellesley Village. Known for its casual, social atmosphere, the venue focuses on games and group activities rather than a traditional dance floor. The bar features pool tables, ping pong, shuffleboard, darts and trivia nights, attracting a mix of locals and visitors looking for a relaxed place to meet and socialise. Drinks include beer, cocktails and bar staples, with a friendly, neighbourhood feel. Located in the heart of Toronto’s main LGBTQ district, Pegasus remains a popular spot for games, drinks and low-key nights out in the Village.

Vibes

Gallery

Location

Pegasus On Church

489b Church St, Toronto, ON M4Y 2C6, Canada

Get directions

Always travel safely and be aware of your surroundings.

WhereIs.Gay rating

4.5

865 reviews

Overall rating across WhereIs.Gay and Google Maps.

Rating by source

  • WhereIs.Gay
    4.4
  • Google Maps
    4.5

Featured Google Maps reviews

Selected by Google Maps. Read more reviews on Google Maps.

Christine Szajko
Christine Szajko

4 months ago

If you’re looking for a bar with great energy, great people, and consistently great service, Pegasus is it! Simon’s trivia nights on Thursday are consistently smart, funny and well-paced. Clearly crafted by someone who actually cares about the experience. It’s the kind of trivia that keeps you coming back week after week not just because it’s challenging, but because it’s genuinely fun and welcoming. The service is always top-tier. Drinks come quickly, the vibe is relaxed, and the staff clearly take pride in what they do. The pool tables are another bonus - they're affordable, well-maintained, and actually playable (which is rarer than it should be).

Review from Google Maps

Dilara Oksuz
Dilara Oksuz

a month ago

Came here with my work bestie for my first ever trivia night and had the best time! The vibe was so fun and welcoming, everyone was super friendly, and trivia was an absolute blast. Can’t wait to come back!

Review from Google Maps

Tim Hewetson
Tim Hewetson

a month ago

Excellent service and good atmosphere. Lately the drink prices are astronomical here. $11.00 plus tip for a bottle of Stella. This is Robbery and pure greed. RIDICULOUS! It’s a shame. This bar is a neighbourhood fixture but won’t be for long if the drink prices remain this high. The rest rooms are also starting to look a little tired. They’ve lasted for 30 years so it’s time for a refresh.

Review from Google Maps

LD BG
LD BG

5 months ago

Great bar, friendly and familiar. Stop in for a good drink of gay juice from David! Also, there is a jukebox which was amazing! Had fun spinning some tunes that night. Nice and diverse crowd. Definitely worth a visit if you are in the village. Perf for they gays and allies alike!

Review from Google Maps

Bram Goldman
Bram Goldman

3 months ago

We went to “Are You Smarter Than a Scottish Guy?” trivia night at Pegasus Bar in the heart of the Village and had an absolute blast. Simon has built a fantastic community around this event , great energy, welcoming crowd, and just the right amount of friendly competition 😈. The questions are clever enough to make you think… and occasionally make you question your own intelligence 🙃 If you’re looking for a fun Thursday night out, this is a must. Come for the trivia, stay for the laughs, and you might even surprise yourself with how much random knowledge is hiding in your brain. Just don’t be shocked if the Scottish guy still wins.

Review from Google Maps

Be the first to review Pegasus On Church

Share your experience to help the LGBTQ+ community find great places.

Claim this listing

Own or manage this venue? Claim this listing to update details, photos, opening hours and contact information.

Help keep this listing accurate

Seen something wrong? Tell us if this venue has moved, closed, changed opening hours or needs an update.

Listing details

Last updated
14 April 2026
Listed in
Toronto › Canada
Data from
WhereIs.Gay community, the venue and Google